The Sedamsville Rectory in Cincinnati, Ohio, is a red-brick priests’ house beside the empty Gothic church of Our Lady of Perpetual Help. It stands in one of the city’s smallest river neighborhoods, the place where Pete Rose was born. Since the parish closed it has become one of the most argued-over haunted houses in America: tenants and ghost hunters describe violent activity, while others who lived there or blessed it say they found nothing. LiveSciFi brought The Demon Files here for an episode that ended with Tim Wood reporting a burning pain in his stomach.

Start on the stairs. Early in the night the team reports a possible shadow and then a push during a staircase session. Watch the staircase session at 8:40.

Sedamsville Rectory location in Cincinnati, Ohio

The Sedamsville Rectory is at 639 Steiner Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45204, next to the former Our Lady of Perpetual Help Church at 637 Steiner Avenue, a short way up from River Road and U.S. 50. The rectory is a private property. Its owner has talked about opening it to overnight guests; check its current listings before you visit, and don’t enter the church or rectory without permission.

Travel Channel’s haunted-destination profile · View location on Google Maps · Explore the LiveSciFi Haunted Locations atlas

Sedamsville Rectory history

A German Catholic parish on the river

Sedamsville grew along the Ohio River in the nineteenth century. In 1878 the neighborhood’s German-speaking Catholics formed their own parish, Our Lady of Perpetual Help, so they could have a German-language school. The cornerstone of the Gothic Revival church was laid on June 10, 1888, and it was dedicated on May 5, 1889. A parish centennial booklet dates the rectory to 1891, built to house the priests of a growing parish. Parish history · WCPO on the rectory.

Decline and closure

Floods and the widening of U.S. 50 cut into the neighborhood in the twentieth century. The parish school closed in 1976, and Our Lady of Perpetual Help closed in 1989, merging with Holy Family in East Price Hill. The church was stripped of its sacred items; its bells, organ and icons went to Holy Family. In 1995 John Klosterman bought the church and rectory from the Archdiocese of Cincinnati. Read the closure and sale history · Clio’s entry on the church.

Why is the Sedamsville Rectory considered haunted?

The Sedamsville Rectory is considered haunted because of reports from former tenants and visiting investigators of scratches, growls, voices and an aggressive, possibly demonic presence. Former tenants promoted the rectory as a paranormal location, and it was featured on Ghost Adventures, Haunted Collector and My Ghost Story. One visiting investigator described a scratch on his face and a colleague whose back scratches formed an upside-down cross. Others disagree. A tenant who lived there from 2006 to 2007 said he never experienced anything, and Father Jack Ashcraft, who performed the blessing shown on television, said the only unusual thing he noticed was a sulfur smell, which he did not consider evidence of anything preternatural. Read both sides.

Priests, names and a burning pain

LiveSciFi’s Demon Files episode leans into the building’s clerical past. Early device readings produce words the team hears as “yes” and “priest,” then “Peter,” “preacher,” “Sally” and a phrase the team discusses as “I confessed enough.” The team revisits the shadow on the stairs, tries a ghost box before taking an Ouija board upstairs, and ends the board session when Tim reports a burning pain in his stomach. Afterward, investigators discuss scratches and trouble seeing. Watch the burning report at 1:02:47.

Watch The Demon Files at the Sedamsville Rectory

The episode moves from a walk-through and recorder questions on the first floor to a threatening ghost-box phrase and an upstairs Ouija session.

The Demon Files at the Sedamsville Rectory episode thumbnail
▶ Watch episode — The Demon Files at the Sedamsville Rectory
TimestampParanormal activityWhat to watch for
2:43Possible shadow figureWatch the walk-through before the first session.
4:58Device: “yes” and “priest”The first response the team connects to the rectory’s history.
8:40Staircase session and a pushA physical report on the stairs.
11:11“Peter” and other wordsDevice readings during recorder questions.
21:29“I confessed enough”The team debates a possible phrase.
22:51Shadow movement on the stairs againThe team returns to the earlier sighting.
43:12A threatening ghost-box phraseThe ghost-box session before the board.
47:52Ouija: “lived”The team asks whether a human is answering.
1:02:47Burning stomach painThe board session ends after Tim’s report.
1:05:00Scratches and difficulty seeingThe team’s closing discussion.

Frequently asked questions about the Sedamsville Rectory

Is the Sedamsville Rectory haunted?

It depends on whom you ask. Tenants and ghost hunters report scratches, voices and growls; a former tenant and the priest who blessed it say they experienced nothing unusual. LiveSciFi’s episode documents device words tied to the rectory’s history, a reported push and a burning pain during the Ouija session.

When was the Sedamsville Rectory built?

A parish centennial booklet dates it to 1891, two years after the church was dedicated.

Can you visit the Sedamsville Rectory?

It is private property. The owner has spoken about renting it to overnight guests; check current listings and don’t enter without permission.

Who owns the Sedamsville Rectory?

John Klosterman bought the church and rectory from the Archdiocese of Cincinnati in 1995 and still owned the rectory when WCPO reported on it in 2017.

Sources and further reading

More Demon Files locations include the Old Tonopah Cemetery and Fort Churchill. Browse the complete Demon Files archive.

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted