I was watching Ghi today I also watched GhostHunters and in both episodes they provoked the spirts? Now this is something I have seen them do many times before with little or no response. Always with the explaination that sometimes it makes the spirts want to come out and interact.
What I want to know is A. Does it work? and B. If it works how and is it safe if it does work?
Is it a form that should be used quite often especially if a spirt is evil or bad or can actually hurt someone.. So my question is does it hinder or hurt an investagation? Or is it something valuable that makes or break an investagation..
Feel free to share what you think...
I know that when GH went to the bar in England, that was built on an old debtor's prison, Barry was teaching Brian to speak in a manner that would have been reflected in the time period the ghosts might have lived.
You know, sometimes I think I find the investigations a lot like teaching middle school students..... different things work for different personalities. Some you push because that is the way to get their attention.... others you might have a more gentle approach.
About 8 years ago I was teaching at a K-8 school that had a ghost of a former teacher roaming around. She would follow the night custodians around and at times even keep doors locked, etc. I found out that she had to have her legs amputated because of being diabetic and refusing to follow a healthy diet. Her last few years she would lock her classroom door when she wanted to binge on chocolate. Apparently, her last few years, she was a very angry and unhappy woman. I finally got an assignment I had been wanting for years.... teaching kindergarden. The room I was going to be assigned to, had been this teacher's room many, many years ago. Before I was to move to the room, a preschool program had been in that room and on the day they were moving out, a full bucket of water went flying across the room for no apparet reason. I went over to the room and knew she was their. I used a very stern voice and told her it was time to move on. She was not going to bother my new students and she no longer had a reason to be there. I reminded her that she had caused her situation and she wasn't going to bother us anymore. It was the last time we ever had any problems.
Kate
Great post Lola, I have very strong feelings in regards to provoking and I'm pretty verbal about it. I'm against provoking 90% of the time. The 10% that I feel is a good reason is when I am trying to get a spirit to come out that was a negative person in life and continues to be a negative energy in death. 2 examples are The Nurse at Wolfe Manor who spent her life intimidating the elderly and infirmed under her care and continues to intimidate these poor souls in death, I provoke her to get her to come out to me so I can let her know she doesn't scare me and that I am there to stand up for those who are still to afraid even after death. The other example is the men who roam the halls of the Burlington, they were evil men in life who used to enjoy torturing and humiliating the ladies who worked there when it was a bordello and in death continue to hate women, I have no problem letting them know how I despise them.
But provoking for the sake of getting something to happen is never ok to me. The spirits that stay behind were at one time people who walked our planet, they were sons, daughters, aunts, uncles, moms and dads when they were alive and should be shown respect in death.
Tim has had things happen to him out of his provoking like the time at the Barn when the electricians tape was thrown at his head by an unseen presence.
I know that provoking is the cool thing to do right now, hell TAPS started provoking and made it acceptable.
I think as a sensitive it is my responsibility to let people know that these spirits are no here to do tricks, to be yelled at and called names just to get something to move or to show themselves so we as investigators have proof. I believe in my heart that with a lot of respect and effort we can get the same results without being rude and mean...
I'd like to pop in this with my 2cents.....In my experience, which is still very new to me, but I'm paying attention....When I go looking for something or request it come out to me...it won't. I only see what I have been chosen to see when IT feels like it, no exceptions in my world...
Great post Lola, I have very strong feelings in regards to provoking and I'm pretty verbal about it. I'm against provoking 90% of the time. The 10% that I feel is a good reason is when I am trying to get a spirit to come out that was a negative person in life and continues to be a negative energy in death. 2 examples are The Nurse at Wolfe Manor who spent her life intimidating the elderly and infirmed under her care and continues to intimidate these poor souls in death, I provoke her to get her to come out to me so I can let her know she doesn't scare me and that I am there to stand up for those who are still to afraid even after death. The other example is the men who roam the halls of the Burlington, they were evil men in life who used to enjoy torturing and humiliating the ladies who worked there when it was a bordello and in death continue to hate women, I have no problem letting them know how I despise them.
But provoking for the sake of getting something to happen is never ok to me. The spirits that stay behind were at one time people who walked our planet, they were sons, daughters, aunts, uncles, moms and dads when they were alive and should be shown respect in death.
Tim has had things happen to him out of his provoking like the time at the Barn when the electricians tape was thrown at his head by an unseen presence.
I know that provoking is the cool thing to do right now, hell TAPS started provoking and made it acceptable.
I think as a sensitive it is my responsibility to let people know that these spirits are no here to do tricks, to be yelled at and called names just to get something to move or to show themselves so we as investigators have proof. I believe in my heart that with a lot of respect and effort we can get the same results without being rude and mean...
Thanks Donna I think also that if its not needed then why do it. I mean why provoke if the spirt is not contacting you with you being nice then what makes you think it will when you are not so nice lol..I dont mean you Donna I mean the you as in general..
Or is the concept that If you dont get a response from someone by being nice then piss them off so they will respond to you? I think thats what it is cause 9 times outta 10 if you say something mean to a person/spirt then they will react as a normal person would in life.. again thanks all keep up the opinions..
I agree with you Donna, I think provoking is for those very few unrully spirits. I feel respect is the best way for a positive experince for the spirit and the living. I think provoking is very grade school, whats next, pulling out a gun and yelling dance spirit dance.
devin
I agree 100% with Donna. I worry about how many spirits that are out there trying to find answers of their own about how they died or getting messages to their loved ones or lost children and they may be the ones getting provoked. A stern voice to make certain ones behave or leave is sometimes needed I agree but one does need to know which ones they are. I mean think about it..........one does not want to talk to a 5 year old child the way they would talk to an adult male who has murdered several women would they? So unless you are a sensitive or really sure about the history concerning the place said to be haunted then you should be careful of provoking in my opinion. I would never forgive myself if I found out I was cussing and screaming at a child. I am just lucky that I have always known what I was up against so far. As it is good that livescifi has Donna and Noreen to let them know what they are dealing with ahead of time.