
What really happened inside the haunted Monroe House in Hartford City, Indiana? The stories surrounding this old house at 218 North Monroe Street are among the most disturbing I have encountered while researching locations for LiveSciFi. Reports of voices, shadow figures, physical encounters and children seen at upstairs windows have made it a destination for paranormal investigators. But the more closely you examine its past, the more important it becomes to separate the documented tragedies from the ghost stories.
I’m Tim Wood, founder of LiveSciFi.tv. In February 2017, our team brought cameras into the Monroe House for a multi-day live-streamed ghost hunt. Viewers could follow the investigation as it unfolded, not just watch an edited TV episode after the fact. Here is the historical background, what drew us to the property, and a later update about the documentary that revisited the case.
Monroe House at a Glance
| Name | Monroe House |
|---|---|
| Location | Hartford City, IN |
| Year built | Disputed |
| Built by | N/A |
| Type of site | Multi-unit residential house |
| Historic designation | N/A |
| Present use | N/A |
| LiveSciFi investigations | 13 episodes with timestamped evidence moments |
| Photographs | N/A |
Where Is the Haunted Monroe House?
The Monroe House stands in Hartford City, Blackford County, Indiana, near the corner of North Monroe and Franklin streets. It is commonly called the “Demon House,” a nickname based on the accounts of investigators and local lore—not a verified classification. The building has served as a multi-unit residence, complicating efforts to determine who lived in which part at different times.
The date of the current structure is disputed in paranormal histories: some accounts trace a house on the property to the mid-1800s, while later historical research distinguishes an older structure from the house that existed around 1900. Without a conclusive chain of building and property records, it would be misleading to present one construction year as settled fact.
The Fractured History Behind the Monroe House Haunting
Hartford City and the Indiana Gas Boom
To understand who lived in the Monroe House, it helps to know what Hartford City was becoming when the house went up. Hartford City began in the late 1830s as a few log cabins and became the seat of Blackford County. It stayed a small farming town until the spring of 1887, when the Hartford City Gas and Oil Company drilled a successful natural gas well and the county joined the Indiana Gas Boom.
Factories followed the free fuel. Manufacturers were lured to Blackford County with promises of free gas, free land and sometimes cash, and the town gained the Hartford City Glass Company, the Sneath Glass Company, the Hartford City Paper Company and others during the 1890s. The Hartford City Glass Company, the first of eight glass plants in town, became its largest employer with about 600 workers at its peak. The population jumped from 2,287 in 1890 to 5,912 in 1900. The boom lasted roughly fifteen years before the gas began to run out, but several glass factories and paper mills kept running, and that industrial town is the world the Berger and Miars families lived in.
The Berger family and the early 1900s
Historical reporting by researcher Celina Summers reconstructed portions of the lives of the Berger family, Belgian immigrants connected to Hartford City’s industrial economy. John B. Berger and his family were prominent local residents. John died of tuberculosis in 1905. Later years brought a series of real misfortunes to relatives, including a shooting, serious injuries, and deaths in the extended family. The newspaper and genealogical trail is more complicated—and more human—than the simplified versions of the haunting legend.
It is tempting to tie every accident or death to the house. We have to resist that temptation. A tragic event involving someone who lived at an address is not the same as a death inside the building, and it does not automatically prove a haunting.
The Miars family and allegations of domestic violence
Summers also found an important March 1907 newspaper report concerning Ulysses G. Miars and Mary Miars, who had occupied an upstairs apartment associated with the property. Mary sought a divorce and made allegations of cruel treatment and being turned out of the family home. The record establishes that these accusations were publicly reported; it does not establish every detail of a paranormal legend about murdered children or a violent death inside the Monroe House.
This distinction matters because one of the house’s most persistent stories involves suffering children. The history contains serious family conflict, but the popular legend goes much further than the surviving evidence.
The 1940 fatal accident
Research into later residents identified Sydney Faulkner, who died in a vehicle accident in 1940 after his car struck a bridge support. The accident is documented in the historical accounts of the household, but it did not take place inside the Monroe House. It is another example of a real tragedy that can be confused with an alleged death at the property itself.
Which Monroe House Legends Are Verified?
For decades, the property has been associated with stories of a deadly fire, child spirits, unexplained lights, voices, dark figures and occult rituals. The fire story in particular is often repeated as established history. Yet Summers reported that her review of local newspapers did not confirm a fatal fire in the current house after 1900, nor the commonly alleged child deaths there. Charred building material, even where present, does not by itself prove the legend’s cause or date.
In other words, the strongest historical story is not a list of proven supernatural deaths. It is a complicated history of families, tragedy, undocumented rumors and witnesses who interpreted unusual experiences as a haunting. That combination is what made this place worth investigating rather than simply repeating a frightening narrative.
The Monroe House Bones: Human Remains in the Basement Crawl Space
The Monroe House drew wider attention when Paranormal Lockdown investigated the location in 2016. During filming, bone fragments were reportedly discovered in a basement crawlspace. This event became a major part of the property’s reputation, and subsequent investigators have continued to discuss the discovery. Accounts differ about the age, identity and meaning of the material; I would not claim that it proves a ritual, murder or demonic presence without conclusive forensic documentation.
There have also been reports of objects interpreted as ritual artifacts found around the property. Such items can be documented as discoveries or claims without concluding that any particular supernatural event caused the experiences inside the home.
The episode was the season two premiere of Paranormal Lockdown, in which Nick Groff and Katrina Weidman spent 72 hours locked inside the house. According to the episode guide, they unearthed skeletal remains in the crawl space during the investigation and notified the authorities. The occult items that became part of the house’s legend were found in the same crawl space, which opens off the basement. Investigators who have written about the house since say the identity of the person whose remains were found has never been established.
The case did not end there. The owner at the time, Eddie Norris, called the pair back because, he said, the activity had grown worse, and Monroe House Revisit aired on April 12, 2018, in the show’s third season. Norris also made and collected unusual pieces for the property, and paranormal teams who visited during his ownership reported that he planned to turn the house into a museum of strange and occult items. Those plans, the remains and the ritual objects together explain why searches for the Monroe House bones still lead people here years after the discovery.
Our 2017 LiveSciFi Live-Streamed Ghost Hunt
In a February 14, 2017 interview with Blogcritics, our team announced a 100-hour Monroe House investigation beginning February 16. We wanted to investigate reports of shadow figures, physical contact, unexplained noises and unusual voices while providing an open, multi-day live broadcast. The audience could watch the conditions in the house unfold in real time.
Going into the investigation, I was concerned by accounts of violent poltergeist-style activity and alleged malevolent entities. Those were my working beliefs and the claims we were testing—not established scientific conclusions. Working with cameras, audio recorders and other investigative equipment can document an experience, but every clip still deserves close examination for equipment faults, environmental causes and context outside the frame.
Unlike a short compilation of highlights, a live-streamed ghost hunt lets viewers see the waiting, setup, technical problems and long periods when nothing unusual happens. That transparency has always been a central part of LiveSciFi’s work.
Watch the Monroe House Investigations and Paranormal Moments
Explore our original Monroe House footage alongside the history above. Open the complete episode archive to search the collection, or choose a timestamp below to watch a specific moment in its original recording.
Selected paranormal moments from our Monroe House episodes
Haunted Monroe House: EVP, Ouija & Ganzfeld Ghost Hunt | LiveSciFiWatch episode- 10:25 — EVP SESSION — Questions about the woman and found rock
- 24:27 — DISEMBODIED SOUND — Team discusses footsteps
- 25:32 — PHYSICAL REPORT — Arm touched and heat reported
- 31:59 — PHYSICAL REPORT — David asks about a scratch
- 53:42 — EVP PLAYBACK — Reviewing the recorder
- 1:23:55 — OUIJA SESSION — Opening questions
Monroe House Mirror Scrying, Pendulum & Ouija Session | LiveSciFiWatch episode
Drawing a Demon at Monroe House | Psychic Drawing & ExplanationWatch episode
Monroe House Final Night: Attic Ghost Hunt & Closing Session | LiveSciFiWatch episodeTim Wood’s Arm Injury and the 2025 Film Evil Unearthed
One of the most unsettling moments associated with my Monroe House investigation was an incident in which I experienced what felt like a sudden, forceful pull. I have described the encounter as a possible demonic attack and reported that my arm was broken during the incident. The footage shows what was recorded; the question of what caused the force is an interpretation, not a fact a camera can independently establish.
The Monroe House returned to the screen in Evil Unearthed (2025), a documentary horror film directed by Matt Benton. The film brings together investigations and footage involving the location. LiveSciFi archive footage of my experience and the arm-injury incident is included in the film, as reported by Tim Wood.
Evil Unearthed was released in the United States on August 1, 2025, and runs 2 hours and 21 minutes. Benton directed and edited it, and it was written by Benton with Sharon Gieseke, Rachel WH and Tanya LaForce West. It follows his Paranormal Research Unit, with Joe Vitale and other team members, working alongside DIG Paranormal and Interface Death to document years of reported activity at the house, including the discovery of ritual items buried in the crawl space. Benton has said the film came out of more than seven years of research and hundreds of hours of footage. It is distributed by Indie Rights and can be streamed on Prime Video, YouTube Movies and Google Play.
Reviews have been split. Film Threat found it unconvincing, while others praised it as years in the making and singled out the testimony of investigators who had frightening experiences in the house. As with any documentary of this kind, what it shows is what the teams recorded and reported; how much of it points to the supernatural is for each viewer to judge.
Footage and film credit: Original LiveSciFi investigation and archival material: Tim Wood / LiveSciFi.tv. Documentary appearance: Evil Unearthed (2025), directed by Matt Benton; documentary released by Indie Rights. The documentary and LiveSciFi investigation are separate productions.
Is It True? What Our Monroe House Cameras and Investigators Documented
Our Monroe House investigation was not just a retelling of a ghost story. We prepared a roughly 100-hour live broadcast, brought cameras and recorders into the house and documented the sounds, reported contact and unsettling experiences as the investigation unfolded. My experience of physical injury became part of that history, and the recordings capture the reactions of people who were actually inside.
The house’s complicated human history deserves equal attention: archival research has challenged some of the most repeated fire and murder legends while revealing other, documented events in the lives of its occupants. That research enriches the haunting story; it does not erase the experiences investigators reported. The original episodes and timestamps are here so viewers can follow both.
Continue through Indiana with our Whispers Estate history and original ghost hunts, or browse the Haunted Locations atlas for more researched locations.
Other Investigations at the Monroe House
Few private homes in the Midwest have been investigated as often. Besides Paranormal Lockdown, our own live broadcast and Benton’s documentary, the house appeared in the series Paranormal Journey: Into the Unknown, in an episode titled The Basement in which the Phantasmic Ghost Hunters were joined by Matt Benton and Joe Vitale. Independent teams have kept coming, among them Paranormal Activity Investigators of Kansas City, who held an overnight investigation on May 14, 2022, and SPIRIT Indiana Paranormal, who made repeat visits and covered the house’s history on their podcast.
The house also sits in a small county with an unusual concentration of haunted sites. Podcasters who toured Blackford County in 2025 counted the Old Blackford County Jail and the Ervin Campbell Speakeasy among several reportedly haunted places within a few miles of the Monroe House, which is part of why investigators who travel to Hartford City often plan more than one night.
Can You Visit the Monroe House?
The Monroe House is a private property at 218 North Monroe Street, on a residential corner in Hartford City, and it is not open for walk-in tours. Over the years, owners have allowed paranormal teams to arrange overnight investigations, and that is the only way inside. If you want to investigate, contact the current owner and arrange access in advance; do not enter the yard or the house uninvited, and be considerate of the neighbors, who live with a steady stream of visitors drawn by the house’s reputation.
If you are traveling to see it from the street, Hartford City is about 20 miles north of Muncie in east-central Indiana. The 1894 Blackford County Courthouse, built at the height of the gas boom and listed on the National Register of Historic Places, anchors the downtown a few blocks away, and you can continue across Indiana to other haunted houses we have investigated, including the Whispers Estate in Mitchell.
From the episode archive
More episodes filmed at Monroe House

Demon Attack Caught on Camera – HAUNTED MONROE HOUSE
February 25, 2017

Monroe House Psychic Drawing Session with Kristin | LiveSciFi
February 21, 2017

Monroe House Ouija & Psychomanteum Chamber | Live Ghost Hunt
February 20, 2017

Searching for Ghosts at Haunted Monroe House | LiveSciFi Archive
February 19, 2017

Real GHOST Caught on TAPE at the Monroe House?
February 17, 2017
Frequently Asked Questions About the Monroe House
Where is the Monroe House?
At 218 North Monroe Street in Hartford City, Blackford County, Indiana, near the corner of North Monroe and Franklin streets.
Were human bones found at the Monroe House?
Yes. Skeletal remains were found in the basement crawl space during the 2016 filming of Paranormal Lockdown, and the authorities were notified. The identity of the person has never been publicly established.
Is the Monroe House the same as the Demon House in Gary?
No. Zak Bagans’ 2018 documentary Demon House is about a different house, in Gary, Indiana. The Monroe House in Hartford City is sometimes called a demon house too, which causes the confusion.
What TV shows and films have featured the Monroe House?
Paranormal Lockdown (2016 and 2018), Paranormal Journey: Into the Unknown, the 2025 documentary Evil Unearthed, and LiveSciFi’s own 100-hour live-streamed investigation in February 2017.
Can you go inside the Monroe House?
Only by arrangement with the owner. It is private property and is not open for public tours.
Explore More of Our Haunted House Investigations
- Sallie House Dark Secret Exposed — our research and experiences at another house associated with claims of a malevolent presence.
- Welles House: A Haunting Worse Than Amityville? — historical research and first-hand investigation at 46 South Welles Street.
- The Haunted History of Waterdog Lake — the local history and our live ghost hunt at the location.
- The 2017 Monroe House Livestream Retrospective — a separate overview of the contemporary broadcast announcement.
- In Search of the Paranormal LIVE — additional original LiveSciFi ghost hunts.
Sources and Historical Research
- Celina Summers, “Exclusive Preview: LiveSciFi’s Tim Wood Takes On The Haunted Monroe House”, Blogcritics, February 14, 2017 (contemporary interview and research).
- Celina Summers, “Paranormal Research Part 1: The Haunted Monroe House”, October 13, 2019 (newspaper and family research).
- Celina Summers, “Paranormal Research Part 2: The Haunted Monroe House”, December 17, 2019 (follow-up historical research).
- Ghost Research Society: Monroe House Investigation, 2019 (independent field report and location background).
- Paranormal Research Unit and Evil Unearthed film listing, 2025 (film identification and credits).
- Paranormal Lockdown, season 2 premiere (2016) and Monroe House Revisit (season 3, April 12, 2018), episode guides
- Paranormal Activity Investigators — Monroe House investigation, May 14, 2022
- The Grave Talks — Evil Unearthed: The Monroe House, with Matt Benton and Joe Vitale (2025)
- Film Threat — Evil Unearthed review (July 2025)
- Indiana Historical Bureau and Blackford County histories — Hartford City and the Indiana Gas Boom



